Search
Skip navigational links
 
 

II. Cases in Lower Courts Addressing Issues in Addition to the Individual Mandate

 
 
  1. Physician Hospital of America v. Sebelius, Dkt. 11-40631 (5th Cir.) (challenging PPACA Section 6001, which limits physician ownership of hospitals)
    1. Physician Hospital of America v. Sebelius, No. 6:10-cv-277 (E.D.Tex. Mar. 31, 2011)
    2. Fifth Circuit Briefs
        1. PHA brief (filed 8/3/11).
        2. Sebelius, et al. brief (filed 10/19/11).
        3. PHA reply brief (filed 11/23/11).
        4. Denial of motion to stay proceedings (1/05/12).
        5. Denial of motion to stay proceedings (2/13/12).
        6. Sebelius, et al. letter (filed 4/5/12).
        7. PHA letter response (filed 4/9/12).
      • Physician Hospitals of America v. Sebelius, Docket 11-40631 (5th Cir. Aug. 16, 2012) (dismissing challenge on the basis that district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction) (filed 8/16/12).
    3. Coons v. Geithner, Docket 2:10-CV-1714 (D.Ariz) (challenging the constitutionality of the Independent Payment Advisory Board created by ACA and the individual mandate)
      1. District court complaint (filed 8/12/10).
      2. Summary judgment briefs
        1. Coons, et al. brief in support of summary judgment (filed 6/20/11).
        2. Geithner, et al. brief in opposition to plaintiff and cross-motion for summary judgment (filed 8/10/11).
        3. Coons, et al. reply brief (filed 8/29/11).
        4. Geithner, et al. reply brief (filed 9/12/11).
      3. Stay order (issued 1/17/12).
      4. Coons v. Geithner, Docket 2:10-cv-01714-GMS (D. Az. 8/31/12) (dismissing challenge to the Independent Payment Advisory Board and requesting additional briefing on whether mandate is consistent with Arizona state law when considered as a tax).
        1. Coons, et al. supplemental brief (9/13/12).
        2. Geithner, et al. supplemental brief (9/31/12).
      5. Coons v. Geithner, Docket 2:10-cv-01714 (D. Az. 12/20/12) (government's summary judgment request and motion to dismiss all remaining claims is granted)

    4. Ass'n of Am. Physicians & Surgeons v. Sebelius, 1:10-CV-499 (D.D.C.) (challenging the employer mandate plus the following issues: (1) the requirement that physicians participate in Medicare Part A to receive social security benefits; (2) the ability of the federal government to promulgate or enforce standards for health insurance; (3) the HHS interim final rule requiring providers to have an HHS-approved enrollment or opt-out record in PECOS in order to refer to Medicare Part B; (4) HHS’ requirement that non-Medicare providers enroll with Medicare, to appear in PECOS, or to obtain an NPI; (6) HHS failure to submit an accounting on the solvency of Medicare and Social Security to the court).
        1. Second amended complaint (filed 9/13/10; case on hold pending SCOTUS decision, the DC circuit's resolution of the Hall case, or SCOTUS granting APPS leave to intervene in Florida case).
        2. Briefs on motion to dismiss
          1. Sebelius, et al. motion to dismiss (filed 11/22/10).
          2. AAPS opposition to motion to dismiss (filed 1/10/11).
          3. Sebelius, et al. reply brief (filed 2/14/11).
          4. Sebelius, et al. supplemental pleading (filed 7/27/12).
          5. AAPS supplemental brief (filed 7/27/12).
        3. Ass'n of Am. Physicians & Surgeons v. Sebelius, Docket 1:10-cv-00499-ABJ (10/31/12) (granting government's motion to dismiss).
        4. Notice of Appeal to D.C. Circuit Court (12/28/12).

      • Federal Exchange Premium Tax Credit Challenge
        1. Pruitt v. Sebelius, 6:11-cv-030 (This action argues that the federally-operated Exchanges are prohibited from providing advance premium tax credits and also that the individual mandate violates the Oklahoma constitution.)
          1. Complaint (filed 1/21/12).
          2. Motion to dismiss (3/28/11).
          3. Pruitt reply to motion to dismiss (4/8/11).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to motion to dismiss (4/26/11).
          5. Order to stay case pending SCOTUS decision (11/16/11).
          6. Order to lift stay (9/12/12).
          7. Amended complaint (9/19/12).
          8. Sebelius et. al motion to dismiss (12/3/12).
          9. Pruit reply to motion to dismiss (1/25/13).
          10. Sebelius response to reply to motion to dismiss (2/8/13).

      • Medicaid Maintenance of Effort Litigation
        1. Mayhew v. Sebelius, 12-2059 (1st Cir. Sept. 13, 2012) (Maine challenged the Medicaid Maintenance of Effort requirement.)
          1. Motion for injunctive relief (9/5/12).
          2. Judgment denying motion for injunctive relief (9/13/12).

      • Conscience Litigation
        1. Calvey v. Obama, Dkt. 5:10-CV-353 (W.D.Okla.) (challenging alleged obligation to fund abortion in addition to the individual mandate)
          1. Second amended complaint (filed 3/25/11; case on hold pending SCOTUS decision (11/8/11)).
        2. Nebraska v. HHS, 4:12-cv-03035 (D. Neb.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. 4:12-cv-03035 (D. Neb.)
            1. Complaint (filed 2/23/12).
            2. Geithner, et al. motion to dismiss (filed 4/30/12).
            3. Nebraska, et al. opposition to motion to dismiss (filed 5/24/12).
            4. Geithner, et al. reply brief in support of motion to dismiss (filed 6/13/12).
            5. Dismissal order (7-17-12) (dismissing all claims against the contraception regulation).
          2. 12-3238 (8th Cir.)
            1. Case docketed (9/25/12).
            2. HHS brief (1/30/13).
            3. Nebraska motion to hold case in abeyance (2/8/13).

        3. Diocese of Fort-Wayne-South Bend v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00159 (N.D. Ind.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation

          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius, et al. motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and memorandum in support of motion to dismiss (filed 8/6/12).
          3. Diocese response to motion to dismiss (filed 8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius, et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 9/24/12).
          5. Diocese motion to consolidate cases (filed 10/2/12).
          6. Sebelius, et al. reply to motion to consolidate cases (filed 10/10/12).
          7. Diocese notice re: motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (filed 11/21/12).
          8. Sebelius, et al. response to notice re: motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (filed 11/28/12).
          9. Sebelius, et al. notice re: motion to dismiss (12/21/13).

        4. Conlon v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-03932 (E.D. Ill.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Amended complaint (filed 8/8/12).
          3. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (filed 8/21/12).
          4. Conlon memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (filed 9/11/12).
          5. Sebelius, et al. reply to memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (10/2/12).
          6. Memorandum opinion and order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (2/8/13).

        5. Archdiocese of St. Louis v. Sebelius, 4:12-cv-00924 (D. Mo.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (filed 8/6/12).
          3. Archdiocese memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (filed 8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 9/24/12).
          5. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (1/29/13).

        6. University of Notre Dame v. Sebelius, 3:12-cv-00253 (N.D. In.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Notre Dame response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to motion to dismiss (9/24/12).
          5. Notre Dame motion for permanent injunction and memorandum in support of same (10/24/12).
          6. Sebelius et al. response to motion for permanent injunction (filed 11/7/12).
          7. Notre Dame reply to response to motion for permanent injunction (filed 11/14/12).
          8. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (12/31/12).

        7. Roman Catholic Archbishop of Washington v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00815 (D.D.C.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Archbishop response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (9/24/12).
          5. Sebelius et al. motion to stay case pending resolution of expedited appeals raising identical issues (filed 10/3/12).
          6. Archbishop memorandum in opposition to motion to stay case pending resolution of expedited appeals raising identical issues (filed 10/17/12).
          7. Sebelius et al. reply to memorandum in opposition to motion to stay case pending resolution of expedited appeals raising identical issues (filed 10/24/12).
          8. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (1/25/13).

        8. Roman Catholic Diocese of Dallas v. Sebelius, 3:12-cv-01589 (N.D. Tex)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Diocese response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 9/24/12).
          5. Sebelius et al. notice of supplemental authority (filed 11/14/12).
          6. Sebelius brief in support of motion to dismiss (2/8/13).
          7. Diocese brief in support of response to motion to dismiss (2/8/13).

        9. Trautman v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00123 (W.D. Pa.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Trautman response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Trautman motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (9/4/12).
          5. Trautman brief in support of motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 9/4/12).
          6. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (9/24/12).
          7. Sebelius et al. brief in opposition to preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 10/16/12).
          8. Trautman reply brief in support on preliminary and permanent injunction (11/8/12).
          9. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (1/22/13).

        10. Franciscan University of Steubenville v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-00440 (S.D. Ohio) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Franciscan University response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 9/24/12).
          5. Franciscan Univ. motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (10/12/12).
          6. Franciscan Univ. brief in support of motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 10/12/12).
          7. Sebelius et al. response in opposition to preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 11/2/12).
          8. Franciscan University reply to response in opposition to preliminary and permanent injunction (11/16/12).
        11. Catholic Diocese of Biloxi, Inc. v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00158 (S.D. Miss.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Diocese response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 9/24/12).
          5. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (12/20/12).
          6. Diocese motion to alter judgment and memorandum in support of (1/8/13).
          7. Memorandum in opposition to motion to alter judgment (1/22/13).
        12. Roman Catholic Diocese of Fort Worth v. Sebelius, 4:12-cv-00314 (N.D. Tex.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Diocese response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. response to motion to dismiss (9/24/12).
          5. Order denying motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (1/31/13).
        13. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of N.Y. v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-02542 (E.D.N.Y.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Archdiocese response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. response to motion to dismiss (9/24/12).
          5. Order granting in part and denying in part Sebelius motion to dismiss (12/4/13).
          6. Sebelius motion to reconsider motion to dismiss (1/11/13).
          7. Archdiocese memorandum in opposition to motion for reconsideration (2/1/13).
          8. Sebelius reply in support of motion for reconsideration (2/8/13).
        14. Zubik v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-00676 (W.D. Pa.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
          1. Complaint (filed 5/21/12).
          2. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
          3. Zubik response to motion to dismiss (8/27/12).
          4. Sebelius et al. motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (9/21/12).
          5. Sebelius et al. brief in support of motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 9/21/12).
          6. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dimiss (filed 9/24/12).
          7. Zubik sur-reply brief to reply to response to motion to dismiss (filed 10/1/12).
          8. Sebelius et al. response to motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 10/15/12).
          9. Zubik response to reply brief to motion for preliminary and permanent injunction (filed 10/25/12).
          10. Dismissal of claims: Zubik v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-00676 (W.D. Pa. Nov. 27, 2012).
          11. Notice of appeal of motion to dismiss (1/23/13).
        15. Belmont Abbey College v. Sebelius
          1. 1:11-cv-01989 (D.D.C.) (challenging the constitutionality of HHS' contraception coverage regulation)
            1. Amended complaint (filed 3/19/12).
            2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (filed 2/16/12).
            3. Belmont response to motion to dismiss (filed 4/23/12).
            4. Judgment dismissing case (filed 7/18/12).
            5. Memorandum denying motion for reconsideration (9/5/12).
          2. 12-5291 (D. Ct. App.)
            1. Belmont brief (10/5/12).
            2. Sebelius et at. reply brief (11/5/12).
            3. Belmont reply brief (11/16/12).
            4. Sebelius et al. response to Belmont reply brief (11/21/12).
            5. Per Curiam order holding cases in abeyance (12/18/12).
        16. Colorado Christian University v. Sebelius, 1:11-cv-03350 (D. Col)
          1. Complaint (filed 12/22/11).
          2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (filed 2/27/12).
          3. Amended complaint (3/22/12).
          4. CCU brief in opposition to mostion to dismiss (3/22/12).
          5. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (5/18/12).
          6. CCU motion to compel (11/9/12).
          7. CCU memorandum in support of motion to compel (filed 11/19/12).
          8. Sebelius et al. brief in opposition to motion to compel (filed 11/28/12).
          9. Order granting Sebelius motion to dismiss (1/7/13).
        17. EWTN v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-00501 (N.D. Al)
          1. Complaint (filed 2/9/12).
          2. Amended complaint (3/21/12).
          3. Sebelius motion to dismiss (5/4/12).
          4. EWTN response to motion to dismiss (6/1/12).
          5. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (6/25/12).
        18. Priests for Life v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00753 (E.D.N.Y.)
          1. Complaint (2/15/12)
          2. Amended complaint (5/14/12)
          3. Sebelius et al. motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (9/12/12).
          4. Priests for life memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (9/12/12).
          5. Priests for life motion to temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
          6. Priests for life memorandum in support of temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
          7. Sebelius et al. memorandum in opposition to temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
          8. Priests for life reply brief in support of temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
        19. Louisiana College v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-00463 (W.D. La.)
          1. Complaint (2/18/12).
          2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (5/11/12).
          3. Amended complaint (6/11/12).
          4. Louisiana College response to motion to dismiss (6/11/12).
          5. Order denying motion to dismiss (7/26/12).
          6. Louisiana College memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (8/13/12).
          7. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (8/24/12).
          8. Order staying case until 8/15/13 (1/4/13).
        20. Ave Maria v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-88 (M.D. Fla)
          1. Complaint (2/21/12).
          2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (5/4/12).
          3. Ave Maria response to motion to dismiss (5/18/12).
          4. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (6/8/12).
          5. Order granting stay of discovery pending resolution of motion to dismiss (11/28/12).
        21. Geneva College v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-00207 (W.D. Pa)
          1. Complaint (2/21/12).
          2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (4/30/12).
          3. Amended complaint (5/31/12).
          4. Geneva response to motion to dismiss (5/31/12).
          5. Sebelius motion to dismiss (8/2/12).
          6. Order denying motion to stay discovery (9/13/12).
          7. Geneva response in opposition to motion to dismiss (9/13/12).
          8. Sebelius et al. reply in support of motion to dismiss (10/4/12).
          9. Sebelius et al. supplemental brief in support of motion to dismiss (11/14/12).
          10. Geneva brief in opposition to motion to dismiss (12/3/12).
        22. O'Brien v. HHS
          1. 4:12-cv-476 (E.D. Mo)
            1. Complaint (3/15/12).
            2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (5/21/12).
            3. Amended complaint (6/11/12).
            4. O'Brien response to motion to dismiss case (6/12/12).
            5. Sebelius motion to dismiss (7/16/12).
            6. O'Brien opposition to motion to dismiss (8/6/12).
            7. O'Brien motion for preliminary injunction (8/23/12).
            8. Sebelius response to reply to motion to dismiss (8/24/12).
            9. Sebelius et al. response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (9/14/12).
            10. O'Brien reply to response to motion for preliminary injunction (filed 9/24/12).
            11. Order of dismissal of all claims (filed 9/28/12).
          2. 12-3357 (8th Cir.)
            1. O'Brien motion for preliminary injunction pending appeal (10/23/12).
            2. O'Brien memorandum in support of preliminary injunction (11/1/12).
            3. O'Brien brief (11/13/12).
            4. Order granting stay pending appeal (11/28/12).
            5. Sebelius brief (12/21/12)
            6. O'Brien reply brief (1/18/13).
        23. Newland v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-01123 (D. Col.)
          1. Complaint (4/30/12).
          2. Motion for preliminary injunction (4/30/12).
          3. Sebelius motion to dismiss (6/8/12).
          4. Sebelius opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (6/8/12).
          5. Amended complaint 6/26/12).
          6. Sebelius motion to dismiss (7/13/12).
          7. Sebelius brief in opposition to preliminary injunction (7/13/12).
          8. Newland response to brief in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (7/17/12).
          9. Order granting preliminary injunction (7/27/12).
          10. Newland response to motion to dismiss (8/30/12).
          11. Appeal of preliminary injunction (filed 9/25/12).
          12. Sebelius et al. reply to response to motion to dismiss (10/3/12).
          13. 10th Cir. referral to mediation, Newland v. Sebelius, No. 12-1380 (10/12/12).
          14. Order to stay proceedings until resolution of 10th circuit appeal (10/26/12).
        24. Legatus v. Sebelius, 2:12-cv-12061 (E.D. Mich)
          1. Complaint (5/7/12).
          2. Motion for temporary restraining order (7/25/12).
          3. Motion for preliminary injunction (8/15/12).
          4. Sebelius response to motion for preliminary injunction (8/29/12).
          5. Order terminating Legatus emergency motion for TRO (9/17/12).
          6. Preliminary injunction order (11/13/12).
          7. Notice of interlocutory appeal re: preliminary injunction (1/14/13).
          8. Order granting motion to stay proceedings (1/31/13).

        25. Wheaton College v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-01169 (D.D.C)
          1. 1:12-cv-01169 (D.D.C).
            1. Complaint (7/18/12).
            2. Motion for preliminary injunction (8/1/12).
            3. Sebelius motion to dismiss (8/10/12).
            4. Wheaton College memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (8/16/12).
            5. Sebelius reply to opposition to motion to dismiss (8/20/12).
            6. Order granting motion to dismiss (8/24/12).
            7. Wheaton College notice of appeal to D.C. Circuit (8/29/12).
          2. 12-5273 (D.C. Ct. App)
            1. Order granting expedited consideration (9/11/12).
            2. Order consolidating cases 12-5291 and 12-5273 (9/20/12).
            3. Wheaton College brief (10/5/12).
            4. Sebelius et al. reply brief (11/5/12).
            5. Wheaton College reply brief (11/16/12).
            6. Per Curium order holding case in abeyance (12/18/12).
        26. Tribune Health Group v. Sebelius, 1:12-cv-06756 (N.D. Ill)
          1. Complaint (8/22/12).
          2. Amended complaint (10/15/12).
          3. Tribune motion for preliminary injunction (11/28/12).
          4. Sebelius reply to motion for preliminary injunction (12/12/12).
          5. Tribune response to Sebelius reply (12/19/12).
          6. Tribune motion for TRO (12/21/12).
          7. Sebelius opposition to motion for TRO (12/22/12).
          8. Tribune reply to Sebelius opposition to TRO (12/24/12).
          9. Preliminary injunction order (1/3/13).
          1. Grace Schools v. Sebelius, 3:12-cv-459 (N.D. In)
            1. Complaint (8/23/12).
            2. Motion to dismiss (11/9/12).
            3. Memorandum in support of motion to dismiss (11/9/12).
            4. Grace Schools response to motion to dismiss (12/7/12).
            5. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (12/14/12).
            1. Catholic Diocese of Nashville v. Sebelius

              1. 3:12-cv-00934 (M.D. Tn.)
                1. Complaint (9/12/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (9/12/12).
                3. Memorandum in support of motion for preliminary injunction (9/12/12).
                4. Motion to dismiss (10/9/12).
                5. Memorandum in support of motion to dismiss (10/9/12).
                6. Catholic diocese response to motion to dismiss (10/22/12).
                7. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (11/5/12).
                8. Order granting motion to dismiss (11/21/12).
              2. 12-6590 (6th Cir).
            2. Tyndale House Publishers v. Sebelius

              1. 12-cv-01635 (D. D.C.)
                1. Complaint (10/2/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (10/8/12).
                3. Sebelius memorandum in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (10/22/12).
                4. Order granting motion for preliminary injunction (11/16/12).
                5. Memorandum opinion granting motion for preliminary injunction (11/16/12).
              2. 13-5018 (D.C. Cir.)
                1. Sebelius notice of appeal (1/18/13).
            3. College of the Ozarks v. Sebelius, 12-cv-3428 (W.D. Mo.)
              1. Complaint (9/17/12).
              2. College of the Ozarks notice of voluntary dismissal (1/14/13).
            4. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Atlanta v. Sebelius, 12-cv-3489 (N.D. Ga.)
              1. Complaint (10/5/12).
              2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (12/10/12).
              3. First amended complaint (12/31/12).
              4. Sebelius motion to dismiss amended complaint (1/14/13).
              5. Archdiocese response in opposition to motion to dismiss (1/31/13).
            5. Autocam Corp. v. Sebelius
              1. 12-cv-01096 (W.D. Mi.)
                1. Complaint (10/8/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (10/10/12).
                3. Brief in support of motion for preliminary injunction (10/10/12).
                4. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (10/12/12).
                5. Sebelius response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
                6. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (12/24/12).
              2. 12-2673 (6th Cir.)
                1. Autocam motion (12/26/12).
                2. Sebelius response in opposition to Autocam motion (12/27/12).
                3. Order denying motion for injunction pending appeal (12/28/12).
                4. Motion to reconsider order denying inunction (12/31/12).
                5. Order denying motion to reconsider previous order (12/31/12).
            6. Korte v. HHS
              1. 3:12-cv-01072 (S.D. Ill.)
                1. Complaint (10/9/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (10/10/12).
                3. Memorandum in support of motion for preliminary injunction (1010/12).
                4. Motion for partial summary judgment (10/10/12).
                5. Memorandum in support of motion for summary judgment (10/10/12).
                6. HHS response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (11/6/12).
                7. Korte reply to response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (11/9/12).
                8. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (12/14/12).
              2. 12-3841 (7th Cir.)
                1. Motion for an injunction (12/18/12).
                2. Sebelius response in opposition (12/21/12).
                3. Korte reply to Sebelius response (12/21/12).
                4. Order granting motion for injunction pending appeal (12/28/12).
                5. Korte brief (1/28/13).
                6. Order granting motion for injunction pending appeal (1/30/13).
            7. East Texas Baptist University v. Sebelius, 12-cv-03009 (S.D. Tex.)
              1. Complaint (10/9/12).
            8. Griesedieck v. Sebelius, 12-cv-03459 (W.D. Mo.)
              1. Complaint (10/19/12).
              2. Motion for preliminary injunction (11/20/12).
              3. Order granting motion for preliminary injunction (12/20/12).
            9. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Miami v. Sebelius, 12-cv-23820 (S.D. Fla.)
              1. Complaint (10/19/12).
              2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (12/21/12).
              3. Archdiocese response to motion to dismiss (1/16/13).
              4. Sebelius reply to response to motion to dismiss (1/23/13).
            10. Grote Industries v. Sebelius
              1. 12-cv-00134 (S.D. In.)
                1. Complaint (10/29/12).
                2. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (12/27/12).
              2. 13-1077 (7th Cir.)
                1. Grote motion for injunction pending appeal (1/11/13).
                2. Sebelius response to motion for injunction (1/17/13).
                3. Grote reply to Sebelius response (1/24/13).
                4. Order granting motion for injunction pending appeal (1/30/13).
            11. Criswell v. Sebelius, 12-cv-04409 (N.D. Tex.)
              1. Complaint (11/1/12).
              2. Sebelius motion to dismiss (1/7/13).
              3. Criswell response to motion to dismiss (1/28/13).
              4. Sebelius reply to Criswell response to motion to dismiss (2/11/13).
            12. Annex Medical, Inc. v. Sebelius
              1. 12-cv-02804 (D. Minn.)
                1. Complaint (11/2/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (11/21/12).
                3. Memorandum in support of motion for preliminary injunction (11/21/12).
                4. Sebelius response in opposition to preliminary injunction (12/12/12).
                5. Annex reply to Sebelius response in opposition to preliminary injunction (12/21/12).
                6. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (1/8/13).
                7. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction pending appeal (1/17/13).
              2. 13-1118
                1. Motion for preliminary injunction pending appeal (1/18/13).
                2. Sebelius response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (1/25/13).
                3. Annex reply to Sebelius response (1/29/13).
                4. Order granting motion for preliminary injunction (2/1/13).
            13. Domino’s Farms Corporation v. Sebelius, 12-15488 (E.D. Mich.)
              1. Complaint (12/14/12).
              2. Emergency motion for TRO (12/21/12).
              3. Sebelius response for TRO (12/25/12).
              4. Order granting TRO (12/30/12).
              5. Motion for preliminary injunction (1/08/13).
              6. Sebelius response to motion for preliminary injunction (1/28/13).
              7. Opinion and order granting motion for preliminary injunction (3/15/13).
            14. Sharpe Holdings, Inc. v. HHS, 2:12-CV-92 (E.D. Mo.)
              1. Complaint (12/20/12).
              2. Motion for TRO (12/20/12).
              3. HHS memorandum in opposition to TRO (12/28/12).
              4. Sharpe reply to HHS memorandum in opposition to TRO (12/30/12).
              5. Order granting TRO (12/31/12).
              6. Order continuing TRO (1/14/13).
            15. Triune Health Group, Inc. v. HHS, 12-cv-6756 (N.D. Ill.)
              1. Complaint (8/22/12).
              2. Amended complaint (10/15/12).
              3. Triune motion for preliminary injunction (11/28/12).
              4. HHS reply to motion for preliminary injunction (12/12/12).
              5. Triune response to HHS reply to motion for preliminary injunction (12/19/12).
              6. Triune motion for TRO (12/21/12).
              7. HHS opposition to motion for TRO (12/22/12).
              8. Triune reply to HHS motion in opposition to TRO (12/24/12).
              9. Order granting preliminary injunction (1/3/13).
            16. Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp. v. Sebelius
              1. 12-cv-6744
                1. Complaint (12/4/12).
                2. Motion for preliminary injunction (12/7/12).
                3. Brief in support of motion for preliminary injunction (12/8/12).
                4. Sebelius response in opposition to motion for preliminary injunction (12/19/12).
                5. Order denying motion for preliminary injunction (1/11/13).

              2. 13-1144
                1. Conestoga expedited motion (1/22/13).
                2. Sebelius reply (1/28/13).
                3. Conestoga response to Sebelius reply (1/29/13).
                4. Order denying request for extraordinary relief (2/7/13).
            17. Catholic Diocese of Peoria v. Sebelius
              1. Complaint (8/19/12).
              2. Sebelius motion to dismiss and memorandum in support of same (10/19/12).
              3. Diocese memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss (11/2/12).
              4. Order granting motion to dismiss (1/4/13).

            Go to the previous section: Challenges to ACA at the U.S. Supreme Court
            Go to the next section: Additional PPACA Litigation Resources

                    © 2017 American Health Lawyers Association. All rights reserved. 1620 Eye Street NW, 6th Floor, Washington, DC 20006-4010 P. 202-833-1100 F. 202-833-1105