Skip navigational links
  • Get Involved

    Learn, Network, and Connect

    Make the most of your AHLA membership! Enroll in a Practice Group, start a conversation on a Discussion List, share your expertise as a mentor, team up with a colleague to speak at a program or write an article, and much more.

    Getting involved makes AHLA a better organization, and creates professional opportunities for you.

     

    Join a Practice Group

    Through membership in AHLA and participation in a Practice Group, you have access to a network of leading attorneys, executives, consultants, and other advisors who are recognized deal-makers and shakers in health care. The connections made as a result of your AHLA membership will provide immediate value.

  • Find a Resource

    Your Source For Relevant Information

    More than ever, we rely on quick and easy access to relevant information for successful practice management. AHLA understands this particular need and offers you many key information sources and services that will help you be effective counsel for your clients.

    AHLA Dispute Resolution Service

    - Arbitration
    - Mediation
    - Peer Review
    - Training and Education
    - Become a Neutral

    Learn more about DRS


  • Get in Touch

    Reach out to AHLA and our health law content experts

    Get in touch with AHLA staff and leaders to find membership support, answers to your questions about programs and webinars, and press/media inquiries. Find your fellow AHLA members with the Member Directory.

    Connect with AHLA on social media!

    Follow AHLA on Twitter or Facebook

    Join our LinkedIn Group

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel


  • Who We Are

    Learn more about AHLA members, leaders, and the organization

    AHLA is the nation's largest, nonpartisan, 501(c)(3) educational organization devoted to legal issues in the healthcare field. Get to know more about our organization, our 12,500 members and leaders, and partnership and sponsorship opportunities.

    Celebrating Diversity+Inclusion

    AHLA is a welcoming, diverse, and inclusive community of those interested in health law.

    Learn more about our Diversity activities


 
 

Addressing Variations in Healthcare Quality: The Role of Medicine and the Law

 
 

Held Friday, May 20, from 1:00 p.m. to 2:15 p.m. Eastern time.

Health Lawyers' Spring 2005 public interest teleconference series began with Addressing Variations in Healthcare Quality: The Role of Medicine and the Law. The speakers were:

  • Elise Dunitz Brennan, Partner, Doerner Saunders Daniel & Anderson LLP, Tulsa, OK (moderator.)
  • Philip G. Peters, Jr., J.D., Ruth L. Hulston Professor of Law, University of Missouri-Columbia School of Law, Columbia, MO
  • John E. Wennberg, M.D., M.P.H., Director, Center for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences, Peggy Y. Thomson Professor for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, NH

Dr. Wennberg and Professor Peters discussed their research on variations in healthcare quality within three categories of care—effective care, preference-sensitive care, and supply-sensitive care—and their recommendation that malpractice liability and informed consent laws be based on standards of practice that are appropriate to each category of care.

In the case of effective care, the legal standard should be that virtually all of those in need should receive the treatment, whether or not it is currently customary to provide it. For preference-sensitive care, the law should recognize the failure of the doctrine of informed consent to assure that patient preferences are respected in choice of treatment; Dr. Wennberg and Professor Peters suggested that the law adopt a standard of informed patient choice in which patients are invited, not merely to consent to a recommended treatment, but to choose the treatment that best advances their preferences. In the case of supply-sensitive care, Dr. Wennberg and Professor Peters suggested that physicians who seek to adopt more conservative patterns of practice be protected under the “respectable minority” or “two schools of thought” doctrine.

Dr. Wennberg participated in Health Lawyers’ recent Public Interest Colloquium, “Medical Necessity: Current Concerns and Future Challenges.” His comments on the teleconference included insights he gained at the Colloquium on potential linkages between his research on practice variations and efforts to improve the policies and guidelines that govern medical necessity determinations. Time was provided for questions and discussion with callers.

The $25 registration fee paid for one connection charge and allowed as many individuals as would like to participate on a speaker phone from that site.

Speaker's Biographies

Teleconference Materials:
Wake Forest Law Review (article)
Practice Variation in Medical Necessity (presentation)
Variation in Use of Medicare Services Among Regions and Selected Academic Medical Centers: Is More Better? (article)

© 2014 American Health Lawyers Association. All rights reserved. 1620 Eye Street NW, 6th Floor, Washington, DC 20006-4010 P. 202-833-1100 F. 202-833-1105